Constructive criticism can help you develop something good into something great.
Feel free to tell me, “You’re doing it all wrong!” Then, I can fix it.
But, how can you give and receive criticism without it being taken the wrong way? It’s not always easy.
A friend recently gave me a piece of criticism. After mulling it over, I could see her angle. I also could see several other angles coming into play.
I’ve been more aware of what I’ve been doing lately because of her criticism (which could be seen more as a piece of advice). PickTheBrain had a lot of great advice on taking criticism. I think one of the best points made was to ask what you can do better.
You can help others with constructive criticism.
I recently critiqued a resume and writing sample for a PRSSA member at another chapter. I enjoy helping others when I can. PickTheBrain also has advice on the art of giving criticism.
The best thing you can do when giving criticism is tell the person exactly how they can improve.
Don’t say: “You need to rework your resume.”
Say: “Your bullet points need work. I would suggest developing them into measurable accomplishments rather than just job duties.”
Don’t say: “This press release needs work.”
Say: “I think it would be better if you focused your lead on this aspect. Then lead into the next paragraph with more information.”
So don’t tell me I’m doing things wrong. Instead, tell me how I can improve.
Rachel M. Esterline works as an account executive for Central Michigan Life, the nationally award-winning school newspaper at Central Michigan University. She is as an account executive for PR Central, CMU’s student-run public relations firm and as a public relations executive with the Student Government Association. Additionally, Rachel serves on the executive board of the Public Relations Student Society of America at CMU and has completed a seven-month internship with her university’s public relations and marketing department. Rachel will graduate in May 2010 with a degree in public relations with minors in journalism and communication.
February 19th, 2009 at 1:25 pm
Positive critisism can always be helpful but people don’t want advice or critisism if they’re not asking for it.
If I do something and ask others what they think of it, I must be prepared to accept their advice or critisism. If I am not specifically requesting comments, I’d often rather not recieve them, even if they may be beneficial.
critisism is often just an annoyance.